What Pets Actually Want & Need | Dr. Karolina Westlund

What Pets Actually Want & Need | Dr. Karolina Westlund

Predatory Sequences and Breed Specialization in Dogs

Dogs carry within them a legacy of the natural predatory sequence inherited from their wolf ancestors—a series of instinctive behaviors that range from initial observation to the final act of capture and even dissection. Over time, this sequence has been selectively honed by human intervention, resulting in breeds that excel in particular steps of the process. For example, pointer breeds are celebrated for their exceptional sense of smell and their ability to detect prey at an early stage. Their refined sniffing and pointing behaviors are precisely the traits that made them indispensable during hunting, as they can locate prey effectively without needing to pursue the chase extensively.

Other breeds demonstrate a different emphasis. Border collies, for instance, showcase a propensity for chasing and stalking without necessarily progressing to the grabbing phase. Their movements are both fluid and calculated, reflecting a well-balanced mix of natural instinct and selective breeding aimed at optimizing herding and controlled pursuit. In contrast, greyhounds are almost exclusively attuned to the chase; their sleek build and bursts of speed are ideal for pursuing targets over long distances, making them excellent runners and trackers in the racing world as well as in certain hunting scenarios.

Terriers stand out by preserving the more aggressive components of this predatory repertoire. They retain strong the grabbing and biting tendencies, traits that have been purposefully emphasized to aid in rodent control. This selective breeding has enabled terriers to become skilled at tackling small, agile prey, maneuvering through tight spaces with determination and precision. Meanwhile, breeds such as livestock guardian dogs have been developed to minimize these predatory impulses altogether, maintaining primarily a keen sense of smell without progressing to the more confrontational stages of the predatory sequence.

This diverse specialization across breeds not only highlights the adaptability of canine behavior but also underscores the significant role human intervention has played in shaping these natural instincts. By selectively breeding for specific aspects of the inherent predatory sequence, humans have created a range of dog breeds that fulfill very particular roles—from subtle, early-stage detection to full-blown, physically demanding pursuits—thereby illustrating the intricate connection between wild ancestry and modern canine functionality.

Modern Dog Training and Communication Cues

Modern dog training today moves away from outdated dominance theories toward building clear expectations and positive, trust-based relationships. Trainers focus on techniques that reward desired behaviors rather than simply enforcing control. For example, rather than demanding that a dog “obey” simply because the owner is in charge, a trainer might teach a dog to stay by its side, making it clear that pulling ahead leads to an unpleasant but structured consequence. This method helps the dog understand that staying close is not only expected but also rewarding, creating a safe space for learning and growth.

Another fascinating aspect of modern training is the detailed understanding of canine communication cues. Research has shown that dogs communicate a lot through subtle body language, such as the direction of their tail wag. A tail wag predominantly to the left may indicate the dog is experiencing negative emotions, while a wag to the right suggests a more positive state. Moreover, trainers recognize playful signals—like a “down dog” stretch, which resembles a yoga pose—as important meta signals that invite play rather than signal aggression. This nuanced understanding allows trainers and pet owners to better interpret what their dogs are feeling and adjust their interactions accordingly.

Daily practices also support modern training goals. Aligning meal times and using techniques like scatter feeding or snuffle mats engages dogs mentally, reducing anxiety and boredom. These activities not only stimulate natural foraging behaviors but also help dogs regulate their arousal levels, making them more balanced and less prone to stress in overstimulating environments. Together, these approaches show that by appreciating the complexity of canine communication and behavior, modern training can effectively meet what pets actually want and need—a nurturing relationship that promotes both well-being and a deeper mutual understanding between human and dog.

Play Signals and the Nuances of Canine Empathy

Dogs communicate much more with their subtle body language than many of us realize, especially during play. For instance, playful postures like the “down dog” stretch—a full front-leg stretch that mirrors a yoga pose—act as powerful signals indicating, “I’m not being aggressive; I just want to have fun.” This behavior, along with familiar play bows and activity shifts, helps balance interactions during playtime. Experts have noted that even in competitive dog games, actions such as roll reversals or self-handicapping (where a larger dog might deliberately underperform in a tug-of-war) keep the game enjoyable and non-threatening for all participants, reinforcing the shared understanding that play is a safe, friendly activity.

Beyond play, research and observation suggest that dogs may also have a genuine sense of empathy. Anecdotes shared by experts include touching moments where a dog gently places its paw on a grieving human’s knee, an act that many interpret as an effort to provide comfort. Such behavior isn’t just about seeking reward; it hints at an emotional sensitivity that may mirror the complex social mechanisms seen in other species. Rather than simply reading human reactions, dogs appear to engage with a deep, often instinctual understanding of their human companions’ emotional states. This empathetic response could be an evolutionary trait that supports communal living and helps buffer negative emotions among group members.

Together, these playful signals and empathetic gestures illustrate how dogs navigate their world with a rich, nuanced language that goes far beyond barks and tail wags. Their ability to indicate play intent and respond sensitively to human emotions underscores a sophisticated level of social interaction—one that truly reveals what our canine friends actually want and need: connection, understanding, and a safe space to express their natural behaviors.

Health Optimization: AG1 Supplements and Red Light Therapy

In the conversation on overall health optimization, the discussion highlights two innovative ways to support physical well-being that also resonate with the natural rhythms observed in our pets. AG1, a carefully formulated vitamin-mineral-probiotic supplement enriched with adaptogens, is presented as a practical tool for sustaining gut health. By nourishing the digestive system, AG1 not only supports efficient digestion and a balanced immune response but also contributes to clearer brain function and optimal hormone regulation. These benefits are especially relevant for those looking to maintain steady energy levels and resilience in the face of daily stresses—a concept that parallels the natural, instinct-driven responses seen in healthy animals.

Complementing this, the speakers introduce red light therapy devices by JWV, which use clinically proven red and near-infrared wavelengths to enhance muscle recovery and improve skin health. The therapy is designed to reduce inflammation and support mitochondrial function, thereby accelerating recovery and boosting overall physical performance. Such technology reflects the emerging trend of using non-invasive, scientifically backed methods to address bodily recovery—a practice that can be just as beneficial for our pets as it is for us. Together, these two methods underline a broader theme of optimizing health through targeted, natural strategies that honor the body’s inherent ability to heal and perform.

Fairness and Social Dynamics in Primates and Felines

In exploring fairness and social dynamics, the discussion draws intriguing parallels between primates and felines, highlighting how each group navigates social relationships and resource allocation in its unique way. In studies with capuchin monkeys, for example, an experiment demonstrated that individuals react negatively when faced with unequal rewards—one monkey receiving a less preferred food item in comparison to a favored treat given to its peer. This response underscores an inherent sensitivity to fairness, suggesting that even non-human primates are finely tuned to discrepancies in resource distribution, which likely plays a role in maintaining social cohesion and cooperation within their groups.

The conversation then shifts to domestic cats, examining how their solitary yet occasionally social nature impacts their behaviors. Unlike primates, cats are primarily independent hunters, yet their interactions in group settings—such as during kitten socialization or in environments where they may share resources—highlight subtle social dynamics. Observations of behaviors like retrieving prey or engaging in playful interactions (even with objects like tin foil balls) reveal that while felines exhibit individualistic tendencies, they are also influenced by their early experiences and environmental cues. This mixture of independent and social conduct illustrates that, much like primates, cats navigate complex social landscapes where fairness and resource sharing can impact their daily lives.

Together, these examples reveal that both primates and felines, despite their distinct evolutionary backgrounds, are governed by similar principles of social balance. The capuchin monkeys’ aversion to unequal treatment and the finely honed social cues of cats in shared spaces speak to an underlying drive towards equitable interactions—an essential component not just for survival, but for maintaining harmonious relationships within communities.

Neural Allocation, Domestication, and Ethical Zoo Practices

Neural allocation plays a fascinating role in understanding both human and animal behaviors. For example, a significant portion of the human brain—around 40%—is dedicated to vision, while large areas also support motor functions, touch, and smell. This specialized “neural real estate” not only reflects the evolutionary priorities that have helped our species adapt and thrive, but it also offers insights into how animals prioritize sensory information for survival. In some instances, alternative sensory areas can even take over, as observed in individuals who rely more heavily on touch and sound, such as braille readers, demonstrating the brain’s remarkable plasticity.

This neural specialization ties in closely with the domestication of animals. Taking dogs as an example, scientists suggest that the ancestors of domestic dogs were the wolves that naturally gravitated toward human settlements—likely the boldest and least fearful among their kind. These wolves forged a symbiotic relationship with humans without deliberate selective breeding at first, instead benefiting from the relative safety and food sources near human habitations. Over time, humans began to steer the natural predatory tendencies of these canids, accentuating traits that supported specific roles, from pointing and chasing behaviors in hunting dogs to the protective instincts seen in livestock guardians. This process of domestication finely illustrates the interplay between inherent neural capacities and selective human intervention.

Ethical zoo practices present a more complicated challenge, intersecting with our understanding of natural behavior and environmental needs. Contemporary zoos strive to move beyond the outdated menagerie model by focusing on conservation and educational roles. Nonetheless, providing a naturalistic habitat for large carnivores remains a persistent ethical dilemma. For instance, one anecdote recounts a tiger named Tatiana at the San Francisco Zoo who, when provoked by children tossing objects near its enclosure, managed to escape and then methodically targeted two individuals before being subdued. This incident prompts reflection on whether the animal’s behavior was purely instinctive or if it hinted at a deeper level of consciousness and intentionality—a question that resonates with broader debates about captivity and animal welfare.

Integrating the science of neural allocation with a history of domestication and the pressing ethical issues in zoo management offers a rich tapestry for understanding what pets—and indeed all animals—truly need. Whether it’s adjusting sensory environments, ensuring proper stimulation for domestic animals, or creating more humane habitats in zoos, these insights emphasize a balanced approach that respects both the biological heritage and the evolving ethical standards in our interactions with animals.

Arousal Regulation and Cognitive Engagement Through Natural Behaviors

Dogs naturally benefit from engaging activities that help regulate arousal while promoting cognitive engagement—a balance that can be essential for both managing anxiety and encouraging mental stimulation. For example, trainers often tap into the natural predatory sequence by guiding dogs to focus on the early stages of behaviors like sniffing and pointing. Instead of permitting a full chase that might escalate stress or aggression, activities such as nose work or controlled sniffing games allow dogs to direct their energy in a more constructive way. This approach not only moderates arousal levels but also provides a safe outlet for instinctual behaviors.

Additionally, incorporating cognitive challenges into daily routines can have a profound impact on a dog’s overall well-being. Using scatter feeding or interactive tools like snuffle mats encourages dogs to think and work for their food, turning mealtime into an engaging mental exercise. This strategy is particularly valuable for dogs living in urban environments where constant sensory bombardment can lead to stress and boredom. By making food retrieval a puzzle to solve, pets receive both a nutritional reward and the mental engagement they need to maintain a balanced state.

Overall, by harnessing natural behaviors in a controlled context, pet owners can help their dogs manage their natural arousal levels while boosting cognitive function—a dual benefit that aligns perfectly with the broader insights shared by Dr. Karolina Westlund on what pets truly want and need.

Imprinting and Attachment: Innate Social Role Development in Animals

Animals exhibit remarkable innate processes that guide them in recognizing who they are, who belongs to their social group, and how they are meant to interact with others—a dynamic interplay captured in the concepts of imprinting and attachment. Imprinting is largely a sensory-driven, immediate process that occurs early in life. For example, in water birds, females have an innate ability to recognize and selectively respond to certain male characteristics, while males depend on early-life exposure to maternal figures to develop their preferences and social roles. This mechanism ensures that mating occurs between well-matched partners, preventing cross-species mishaps and unproductive courtship behaviors. Similar patterns are observed in captive breeding scenarios, such as with discus fish and cuttlefish, where species-specific cues guide appropriate mate choice, and even in some insect studies involving fruit flies, highlighting how deeply ingrained these processes are across the animal kingdom.

In contrast, attachment develops over a longer period through ongoing interactions with a caregiver. This gradual bonding process is critical for establishing a secure base from which an animal can explore its environment and learn to regulate its emotions. In domesticated dogs, for instance, researchers use the "strange situation test" to evaluate whether a puppy displays secure, anxious, or avoidant attachment patterns when reunited with its caregiver. A secure attachment not only supports the dog’s emotional well-being but also influences its social behavior and ability to interact effectively with other animals and humans. Together, imprinting and attachment form the foundation of an animal’s social role development, ensuring that while imprinting provides the blueprints for inherent social preferences, attachment solidifies these roles through nurturing and continuous social engagement.

Hormonal Influences and Early Socialization in Canine Attachment

The discussion on hormonal influences and early socialization in canine attachment reveals how deeply intertwined a dog’s emotional development is with both their hormonal balance and early-life experiences. Research from the 1960s highlighted that delaying separation beyond three to six weeks can be crucial, as puppies that form secure early bonds tend to develop a stable sense of self-regulation. This self-regulation, in turn, supports their ability to handle stress and adjust to new social environments. In essence, a secure early attachment not only nurtures emotional well-being but can also lessen the need for more intensive socialization efforts later in life.

Personal anecdotes add a practical dimension to this scientific understanding. One speaker, with a background in hormonal research, recounted his own experience of neutering his dog at six months old. He observed that early removal of androgens led to unexpected challenges, including joint discomfort and rapid nail growth as the dog aged. In response, he experimented with weekly testosterone injections which, remarkably, restored his pet’s vigor and reduced joint pain. This experience underscores the delicate balance between hormonal influences and the physical and behavioral health of dogs, suggesting that maintaining natural hormone levels might play a pivotal role in ensuring a robust attachment and overall well-being.

Cultural perspectives further enrich the conversation. In some countries, such as Norway and Western Australia, neutering is either restricted or mandated only under specific conditions, prompting a reevaluation of conventional practices. Instead of completely removing hormone-producing gonads, alternative procedures like a basectomy—a technique that prevents reproduction without eliminating hormone production—are proposed as potential strategies to preserve the natural hormonal milieu. This approach highlights the broader debate on how best to support canine health and attachment, blending scientific insight with practical caregiving considerations.

Together, these insights emphasize that early social experiences and balanced hormonal influences are fundamental for fostering secure attachments in dogs. Understanding and integrating these factors can lead to not only more emotionally resilient pets but also a deeper appreciation of the subtle ways that biology and early life shape the behaviors and needs of our canine companions.

Neutering Debates: Cultural Perspectives and Alternative Approaches

In the discussion on neutering debates, cultural perspectives and alternative approaches emerge as key themes that challenge conventional veterinary practices. The speaker shares a personal anecdote about choosing to neuter his dog at six months of age, a decision made out of both necessity and scientific caution given his background in hormonal research. Over time, the dog developed issues such as joint pain and rapid nail growth—a series of complications that prompted the speaker to experiment with weekly testosterone injections. Remarkably, this hormone supplementation reinstated the pet’s vigor and reduced joint discomfort, suggesting that preserving hormonal production might have long-term health benefits that traditional neutering could otherwise compromise.

Cultural differences further complicate the neutering debate. For instance, in countries like Norway, neutering is typically restricted to cases with clear medical indications, while in Western Australia, it is mandated unless the owner intends to breed. These varying regional practices underscore a broader discussion about whether the complete removal of hormone-producing gonads is always in the best interest of canine health. Some experts propose alternative procedures—such as a basectomy that severs the reproductive connection without eliminating hormone production—as a potential compromise. This approach could balance the need for population control while safeguarding the natural hormonal functions that contribute to physical and behavioral well-being.

Overall, the conversation encourages pet owners and veterinarians alike to consider the nuanced implications of neutering. It suggests that by reevaluating established methods and exploring alternatives that maintain hormonal integrity, we might better support the overall quality of life for our pets.

Watch the original video